Skip to content
GuidesUpdated · Published 2026-10-07Forex Guide

How to Compare Forex Spreads Between Brokers (Step by Step)

A practical method to compare forex spreads: average vs 'from' spreads, adding commission, testing on demo, and the all-in cost per lot formula with examples.

8 min read

Reviewed by · Lead Prop Firm & Quantitative Risk Analyst

Reviewed using our forex & CFD broker review methodology

Vantage Markets logo
Vantage Markets 4.1/5 · ASIC + FCA Tier-1 & Global
Verified 2026 Specs
Checked
150% + 25% Deposit Credit (Offshore Entities Only — Not FCA/ASIC) Valid through Dec 31, 2026 (VFSC Entity)
4.2/5
Trustpilot
FCA + ASIC
Tier-1 Entities
$50
Min. deposit
1,000+
Instruments
How to Compare Forex Spreads Between Brokers (Step by Step) — verified 2026 research cover
Vantage Markets logo
Vantage Markets 4.1/5
Valid through Dec 31, 2026 (VFSC Entity)

To compare forex spreads accurately between two brokers, ignore the advertised "from 0.0 pips" marketing banner and calculate the average all-in dollar cost per standard lot across your actual trading pairs and session hours. Every valid spread comparison uses the universal all-in formula:

All-In Cost per Lot = (Average Realized Spread in Pips × Pip Value) + Round-Turn Commission

On EUR/USD (where 1 standard lot = 100,000 EUR and 1 pip = $10.00), a commission-free Standard account averaging 1.2 pips costs $12.00 per lot, whereas a Raw ECN account averaging 0.1 pips plus a $6.00 round-turn commission costs $7.00 per lot. Because floating spreads expand and contract across the 24-hour trading day, logging live demo spreads across the Asian session, London Open, New York Overlap, and 17:00 NY Rollover for five trading days is the only scientific way to pick the cheaper broker.

6-Step Method to Compare Forex Spreads Like a Pro

  1. Select the 2 to 3 exact symbols you trade most: Never judge a broker solely by EUR/USD if 70% of your volume is in XAU/USD (Gold), GBP/JPY, or US100 (Nasdaq). Some brokers subsidize EUR/USD as a "loss leader" while charging wider spreads on gold and cross pairs.
  2. Open matching account tiers on demo (or micro-live): Compare apples to apples—either compare Raw ECN vs Raw ECN (e.g., Vantage Raw ECN vs VT Markets RAW ECN vs Exness Raw Spread) or Standard STP vs Standard STP.
  3. Enable the Spread column in MetaTrader 4 / MetaTrader 5: Right-click inside the MT4/MT5 Market Watch window and check Spread. Remember that MetaTrader displays spreads in points (pipettes), not pips—so a reading of 12 on a 5-decimal EUR/USD quote means 1.2 pips, and 1 means 0.1 pips.
  4. Convert per-side commission into pip equivalents: On major USD pairs where 1 pip = $10.00 per standard lot, a $6.00 round-turn commission ($3.00/side) equals 0.60 pips, and a $7.00 round-turn commission ($3.50/side) equals 0.70 pips.
  5. Sample spreads across 4 distinct liquidity windows for 5 days: Record readings during quiet Tokyo hours (02:00 UTC), the London Open (07:30 UTC), the London–New York Overlap (13:30 UTC), and the daily bank Rollover window (21:00–22:05 UTC).
  6. Compare both the Mean (Average) and the 90th-Percentile Spike: A broker that averages 0.1 pips during quiet hours but widens to 4.5 pips on routine macro releases can cost you more in slipped stop-losses than a broker with a rock-steady 0.2-pip book.

Worked Multi-Asset & Multi-Session Spread Comparison (EUR/USD, GBP/JPY, XAU/USD)

To see how spread math changes across sessions and instruments, let's compare three account structures across EUR/USD ($10/pip), GBP/JPY (~$6.70/pip at USD/JPY 149.00), and XAU/USD Gold ($1.00 per 1-cent move on a 100 oz lot):

  • Broker A (Standard STP): $0 commission; markup built into spread.
  • Broker B ($6.00 Raw ECN — e.g., Vantage / VT Markets / JustMarkets): Raw spread + $6.00 round-turn commission per lot.
  • Broker C ($7.00 Raw ECN — e.g., PU Prime / Exness Raw / Global Prime): Raw spread + $7.00 round-turn commission per lot.
Instrument & Trading Session Window Broker A: Standard STP ($0 Comm) Broker B: $6.00 Raw ECN (Spread + $6) Broker C: $7.00 Raw ECN (Spread + $7) Cheapest Option & Savings per 10 Lots
EUR/USD — London / NY Overlap (13:30 UTC) 1.2 pips = $12.00 / lot 0.1p ($1) + $6 = $7.00 / lot 0.1p ($1) + $7 = $8.00 / lot Broker B (Saves $50 per 10 lots vs Std)
EUR/USD — Asian Session (02:00 UTC) 1.5 pips = $15.00 / lot 0.3p ($3) + $6 = $9.00 / lot 0.3p ($3) + $7 = $10.00 / lot Broker B (Saves $60 per 10 lots vs Std)
GBP/JPY — London Session (08:30 UTC) 2.2 pips (~$14.74) = $14.74 / lot 0.5p ($3.35) + $6 = $9.35 / lot 0.5p ($3.35) + $7 = $10.35 / lot Broker B (Saves $53.90 per 10 lots vs Std)
XAU/USD Gold — NY Session (14:00 UTC) 25 cents ($0.25/oz) = $25.00 / lot 8 cents ($8) + $6 = $14.00 / lot 8 cents ($8) + $7 = $15.00 / lot Broker B (Saves $110 per 10 lots vs Std)
EUR/USD — Daily 17:00 NY Rollover (5 Mins) 5.0 to 8.0 pips = $50–$80 / lot 3.5p ($35) + $6 = $41.00 / lot 3.5p ($35) + $7 = $42.00 / lot Avoid trading during rollover!

Look at the numbers across a 30-lot monthly mix (10 lots EUR/USD Overlap + 10 lots GBP/JPY + 10 lots XAU/USD):

  • Broker A (Standard STP) Total Monthly Cost: $120 + $147.40 + $250 = $517.40 / month ($6,208.80 / year).
  • Broker B ($6.00 Raw ECN) Total Monthly Cost: $70 + $93.50 + $140 = $303.50 / month ($3,642.00 / year).
  • Net Annual Savings: Simply running this side-by-side spread audit and choosing a $6.00 Raw ECN tier saves $2,566.80 per year on 30 lots a month! You can plug your own pairs and lot sizes into our Profit Calculator and Drawdown Calculator.

Ready-to-Use 5-Day Spread Log Template

Copy this table into a spreadsheet and log the MT4/MT5 Market Watch spread (converted from points to pips) across five trading days before funding a new broker:

Time (UTC) Session Context Pair Broker A (All-In Pips / $) Broker B (All-In Pips / $) Notes & Order Book Depth
01:00 UTC Tokyo / Asian Session USD/JPY Check cross-pair liquidity
07:00 UTC London Market Open EUR/USD, GBP/USD Peak European trend volume
12:30 UTC US CPI / NFP Release EUR/USD, XAU/USD Check spike width & recovery speed
14:00 UTC London–NY Overlap XAU/USD, NAS100 Tightest global institutional spreads
21:05 UTC 17:05 NY Bank Rollover EUR/USD, AUD/NZD Measure worst daily rollover widening

4 Expensive Mistakes Traders Make When Comparing Spreads

  • Mistake 1: Confusing MT4/MT5 "Points" with "Pips": On a 5-digit broker (where EUR/USD is quoted as 1.08505), the fifth decimal place is a point (0.1 pips). When the MT4 Spread column shows 11, the spread is 1.1 pips, not 11 pips. On XAU/USD quoted to 2 decimal places (2600.05), a spread reading of 12 means 12 cents ($0.12/oz = $12.00 per 100 oz lot).
  • Mistake 2: Comparing a "Minimum" Spread Against an "Average" Spread: Broker A might advertise "Spreads from 0.0 pips" (minimum achieved for 3 seconds a day) with a true daytime average of 0.35 pips, while Broker B publishes its audited average spread of 0.15 pips. Always compare daytime averages.
  • Mistake 3: Ignoring Bid vs Ask Trigger Mechanics on Short Trades: In MetaTrader and TradingView, chart candlesticks are drawn using the Bid price. When you are Short (Sell), your Stop-Loss and Take-Profit are triggered by the Ask price (Bid + Spread). If a broker's spread widens to 6 pips at 17:00 NY rollover, the Ask line jumps 6 pips above the candle high and can stop out your short trade even though the chart candle never touched your price level!
  • Mistake 4: Forgetting Overnight Swap and High-Impact News Windows: If you hold trades past 17:00 NY time, a $2.00 spread difference is dwarfed by a -$10.00 to -$40.00 overnight swap charge (swap calculator guide). Similarly, always check when tier-1 macro data drops on our Economic Calendar so you don't mistake a temporary NFP spread widening for normal daytime pricing.

Related: What is a spread? · Forex broker fees · Best raw spread brokers · Lowest spread forex brokers

Further reading: FCA guidance on CFDs and leveraged products · FCA ScamSmart.

How to Compare Forex Spreads Between Brokers: Your Questions Answered

What is considered a good forex spread on EUR/USD in 2026?

During liquid London and New York trading hours (07:00 to 16:00 UTC), a competitive Standard STP (commission-free) spread on EUR/USD is 1.0 to 1.2 pips ($10 to $12 per standard lot). On a Raw ECN account, a competitive spread is 0.0 to 0.2 pips plus a $6.00 round-turn commission, bringing your all-in cost to $6.00 to $8.00 per standard lot.

How do I convert a Raw ECN commission into pips to compare with a Standard account?

On major currency pairs where the USD is the quote currency (such as EUR/USD, GBP/USD, AUD/USD, and NZD/USD), 1 standard lot (100,000 units) has a fixed pip value of $10.00 per pip. Simply divide the round-turn dollar commission by $10: a $6.00 round-turn commission equals 0.6 pips, and a $7.00 round-turn commission equals 0.7 pips. Add that figure to the raw spread.

Why do forex spreads widen so much at 5:00 PM New York time?

At 5:00 PM (17:00) New York time, the global forex market transitions from the New York close to the Sydney open and processes daily T+2 bank settlement (rollover). For roughly 5 to 15 minutes around 17:00 NY, major tier-1 liquidity banks pause or pull their tight quotes to reset daily risk books, causing spreads across all brokers to widen temporarily—especially on cross pairs.

Are fixed spreads better than variable (floating) spreads?

Almost never for active traders. Brokers that offer fixed spreads operate as market makers and must price the fixed spread wide enough (often 1.8 to 2.5 pips on EUR/USD) to insure themselves against normal daytime volatility, while still reserving the right in their terms to widen spreads or requote orders during high-impact news. Floating Raw ECN spreads are substantially cheaper over a full month.

Why did my short trade get stopped out when the chart candle never touched my stop-loss?

Trading platforms draw default candlestick charts using the Bid price (the price at which you sell). However, closing a Short position requires buying back at the Ask price (which sits above the Bid price by the exact width of the current spread). If the spread widens during news or rollover, the invisible Ask line rises and triggers your stop-loss before the Bid candle reaches it. Always enable "Show Ask Line" in chart settings.

Do demo accounts show the exact same spreads as live accounts?

At reputable ECN and STP brokers (such as Vantage, VT Markets, Exness, and Tickmill), demo servers stream the exact same live bid-ask price feeds as their corresponding live Standard or Raw account types—provided you open the exact same account tier on demo. However, demo accounts simulate order fills instantly without real liquidity book depletion, so large lot sizes on live accounts can experience slightly more slippage during news.

Sources checked 2026-10-01: Vantage, Exness, JustMarkets and HFM account pages (raw commission $6–$7 per round turn).

Sources & verification

Last checked
Written by
HNL Growth Team
Reviewed by
Hà Ngọc Lộc
Length
8 min read

Rules, prices and payout terms on this page were checked against the official websites, help-centre articles and published terms of the firms mentioned, on the date above. Prop firms and brokers change conditions often — confirm the current version on the official site before you buy or deposit. Read our broker review methodology and affiliate disclosure.

Official sources & documentation verified

Explore Related Hubs & Free Trading Tools

Vantage Markets logo
Vantage Markets 4.1/5 · ASIC + FCA Tier-1 & Global
Verified Offer 150% + 25% Deposit Credit (Offshore Entities Only — Not FCA/ASIC)

Ready to Trade with Vantage Markets?

Vantage Markets is a multi-regulated forex & CFD broker (FCA, ASIC, FSCA, CIMA, VFSC) with Raw ECN pricing ($3/side = $6/lot RT), Pro ECN ($1.50/side = $3/lot RT), no deposit/withdrawal fees, and full MT4/MT5/TradingView support. Check which legal entity onboards your country before funding.

FCA (UK, FRN 590299) + ASIC (AU, AFSL 428901) Tier-1 entities
$50 minimum deposit (Standard STP / Raw ECN / Cent)
Raw ECN spreads from 0.0 pips + $3/side ($6/lot RT) · Pro ECN $1.50/side ($3/lot RT)
MT4, MT5, TradingView & Vantage App
Confirm your onboarding entity & leverage cap before funding

Risk disclaimer: Vantage Markets is a live, multi-entity broker — trading forex and CFDs is done with real capital under normal market risk (this is not a simulated prop-firm evaluation). Deposit credit promotions (150% + 25% bonus) and high leverage (above 1:30) are offered exclusively under offshore entities (VFSC/CIMA) and are prohibited for retail clients under FCA (UK) and ASIC (Australia) regulations. CFDs and leveraged forex products are complex instruments and carry a high risk of losing money rapidly due to leverage; most retail investor accounts lose money trading these products. Affiliate disclosure: HNL Growth earns a commission when you open a Vantage Markets account through links on this page.