Skip to content
TickmillLast checked Forex Broker

Tickmill vs Vantage Markets 2026: Raw ECN Fees, Leverage & Safety Compared

In our side-by-side institutional audit across the Tickmill Review 2026 and Vantage Markets Review 2026, we compared raw spread stability, VIP/Pro ECN commission tiers ( $2.00 vs $3.00/lot ), real-cash wallet yield vs…

7 min read

Reviewed by · Lead Prop Firm & Quantitative Risk Analyst

Reviewed using our forex & CFD broker review methodology

Tickmill logo
Tickmill 4.5/5 · FCA #717270 · CySEC · FSCA · Raw $6/Lot
Verified 2026 Specs
Checked
FCA #717270, CySEC & FSCA · Raw $6/Lot RT · $30 Welcome Account + Up to 3.5% Wallet Interest Ongoing 2026 ($30 Welcome Account, 3.5% Interest & Free TradingView)
FCA & CySEC
6 Global Licences
$6/Lot RT
Raw ECN (0.0 Pips)
$100
Min. Deposit
TradingView
MT5, MT4 & DMA
Tickmill vs Vantage Markets 2026: Raw ECN Fees, Leverage & Safety Compared — verified 2026 research cover
Tickmill logo
Tickmill 4.5/5
Ongoing 2026 ($30 Welcome Account, 3.5% Interest & Free TradingView)

Tickmill and Vantage Markets are two of the rare multi-regulated global brokers that break away from the industry-standard $7.00/lot MetaTrader commission by offering $6.00 round-turn ($3.00 per side) Raw ECN pricing right out of the box. Both brokers also maintain UK FCA and South Africa FSCA licenses, integrate directly with TradingView, and offer high offshore leverage (1:1000 on Tickmill vs up to 1:2000 on Vantage).

Verified: November 2026

In our side-by-side institutional audit across the Tickmill Review 2026 and Vantage Markets Review 2026, we compared raw spread stability, VIP/Pro ECN commission tiers ($2.00 vs $3.00/lot), real-cash wallet yield vs deposit credit bonuses, and DMA Futures access. Here is the definitive 2026 breakdown to help you decide which $6.00/lot ECN broker fits your trading capital and strategy.

1. Master 10-Point Comparison: Tickmill vs Vantage Markets (2026)

Comparison Parameter Tickmill (Raw / VIP / Futures) Vantage Markets (Raw ECN / Pro ECN) Category Winner
Year Founded 2014 2009 Vantage
Global Regulatory Licenses UK FCA (#717270), CySEC (#278/15), DFSA (#F007663), FSCA (#49464), Labuan FSA (#MB/18/0028), FSA (#SD008) ASIC (#428901), UK FCA (#590299), FSCA (#51268), VFSC Vanuatu (#700271) Tickmill (Adds EU CySEC, DFSA & Labuan FSA)
Minimum Deposit (Raw ECN) $100 (+$30 No-Deposit Welcome Account) $50 (Raw ECN & Standard STP) Vantage ($50 vs $100 entry)
MT4 / MT5 Raw Commission $3.00 / side ($6.00 round-turn) $3.00 / side ($6.00 round-turn) Tie ($6.00/lot on both)
High-Tier VIP / Pro Commission $1.00 / side ($2.00 round-turn) ($50k VIP) $1.50 / side ($3.00 round-turn) ($10k Pro ECN) Split (Vantage at $10k; Tickmill cheaper at $50k)
EUR/USD Avg Raw Spread 0.10 – 0.20 pips 0.15 – 0.25 pips Tickmill (Tighter raw liquidity)
XAU/USD Avg Raw Spread ~0.09 pips ($9.00/lot) ~0.12–0.15 pips ($12–$15/lot) Tickmill (Tighter Gold ECN book)
Maximum Leverage Up to 1:1000 (30% stop-out) Up to 1:1000 – 1:2000 (10%–20% stop-out) Vantage (1:2000 max tier)
Exchange-Traded DMA Futures Yes (CME, COMEX, NYMEX, CBOT, Eurex) No (OTC CFDs only) Tickmill
Bonuses, Yield & Rebates $30 Welcome + 3.5% Wallet Yield + $0.25–$0.75/lot Cash Rebate 50% Credit Bonus + 13% p.a. Equity Promo (Volume-gated) Strategy-Dependent

2. Raw ECN & VIP / Pro Commission Math: $6.00, $3.00, and $2.00 per Lot

Both the Tickmill Raw Account ($100 min deposit) and the Vantage Raw ECN Account ($50 min deposit) charge $6.00 round-turn commission ($3.00 per side) per standard lot on MT4 and MT5. However, three variables separate their true all-in trading costs:

Tickmill logo
Tickmill ★ 4.5/5
VS
Vantage Markets logo
Vantage Markets ★ 4.1/5
✓ HEAD-TO-HEAD AUDIT VERIFIED
EXHIBIT 05 // HNL COMPARATIVE BENCHMARK MODEL HEAD-TO-HEAD BENCHMARK: TICKMILL VS. VANTAGE MARKETS

Head-to-Head Audit Weighting: Tickmill vs. Vantage Markets Selection Matrix

ACTIVE PROFILE: SCALPER & INTRADAY (EXECUTION COST WEIGHTED 40%)
01. Raw Spread + Commission 40% Weight 02. Stop-Out & Margin Buffer 25% Weight 03. Tier-1 Legal Entity Safety 15% Weight 04. Swap-Free & Holding Cost 10% Weight 05. Min Deposit & Payout Speed 10% Weight ⚡ DECISION RULE: MATCH YOUR #1 WEIGHTED PILLAR TO THE TABLE BELOW BEFORE COMPARING BONUSES OR LEVERAGE
Key Takeaway: When comparing Tickmill vs. Vantage Markets, high-frequency scalpers should weight raw spread plus commission ($6–$7/lot) at 40% of their decision, whereas multi-day swing traders gain more from extended swap-free status and stop-out buffers.
  1. Interbank Spread Tightness (EUR/USD & XAU/USD): Tickmill's pure institutional liquidity aggregation delivers slightly tighter median spreads during London and New York hours (~0.15 pips on EUR/USD and ~0.09 pips on XAU/USD Gold vs ~0.20 pips and ~0.14 pips on Vantage Raw ECN).
  2. Volume Cash Rebates ($0.25 to $0.75/lot): Tickmill automatically pays withdrawable cash rebates on 200+ monthly lots (SD008), cutting your effective Raw commission to $5.25–$5.75/lot.
  3. Pro ECN ($10,000) vs Tickmill VIP ($50,000):
    • If your account balance is between $10,000 and $49,999, Vantage Pro ECN unlocks a $3.00 round-turn ($1.50 per side) commission rate before you qualify for Tickmill VIP.
    • Once your account balance reaches $50,000+, Tickmill VIP drops your commission to an industry-leading $2.00 round-turn ($1.00 per side)—33.3% cheaper than Vantage Pro ECN!

Real 200-Lot Monthly Cost Matrix Across Capital Tiers

Monthly Cost (200 Lots) = 100 Lots EUR/USD Cost + 100 Lots XAU/USD Cost - Cash Rebates

Using our Spread & Commission Calculator, let us compare executing 200 standard lots/month (100 lots EUR/USD + 100 lots XAU/USD Gold) across three account capital levels:

Account Capital Tier (200 Lots/Mo) Tickmill All-In Monthly Cost Vantage All-In Monthly Cost Cheaper Broker & Net Savings
Tier 1: $500 – $9,999 Capital (Raw vs Raw ECN) $2,200 / mo ($1,050 spread + $1,200 comm - $50 rebate) $2,800 / mo ($1,600 spread + $1,200 comm) Tickmill saves $600/mo ($7,200/yr)
Tier 2: $10,000 – $49,999 Capital (Raw vs Pro ECN $3/lot) $2,200 / mo ($6/lot comm + tighter Gold spread) $2,200 / mo ($1,600 spread + $600 comm) Tie (Tickmill tighter spread offsets Pro comm)
Tier 3: $50,000+ Capital (VIP $2/lot vs Pro ECN $3/lot) $1,400 / mo ($1,050 spread + $400 comm - $50 rebate) $2,200 / mo ($1,600 spread + $600 comm) Tickmill VIP saves $800/mo ($9,600/yr)

See our full Tickmill Spreads & Fees Audit, Tickmill Account Types Guide, and Tickmill Gold Trading (XAU/USD) Guide for complete instrument specifications.

3. Promotions Philosophy: Real-Cash Perks vs Deposit Credit Bonuses

Tickmill and Vantage take fundamentally different approaches to client incentives under their international entities:

Tickmill's Institutional Real-Cash Ecosystem (SD008)

  • $30 No-Deposit Welcome Account: New clients receive $30 in live trading capital with zero deposit required; profits between $30 and $100 are fully withdrawable once criteria are met.
  • Up to 3.5% APY Interest on Idle Wallet Cash: Earned automatically on uninvested wallet funds ($1,000+ balance) with minimal activity requirements, paid out in real withdrawable cash every month.
  • Withdrawable Volume Cashback ($0.25–$0.75/lot) & Free TradingView Plans: Real cash rebates credited directly to your account, plus full monthly reimbursement of TradingView Essential, Plus, or Premium plans (50/150/300 lots/mo).

Vantage's Credit Bonus & High-Leverage Ecosystem (VFSC)

  • 50% First Deposit Bonus + 20% Reload Credit Bonus: Vantage credits bonus margin (up to $500 at 50%, then 20% up to $10,000 total credit). Note that credit bonuses cannot be withdrawn directly as cash and may vary in drawdown support depending on the specific promo terms.
  • 13% p.a. Funds Promotion: Vantage offers a high-headline 13% p.a. return on eligible funds, but requires meeting strict daily/weekly minimum lot-volume gates to unlock the payout.

4. Regulation, Platforms & Leverage (1:1000 vs 1:2000)

  1. Regulatory Footprint (6 vs 4 Licenses): As verified in our Is Tickmill Safe? 6-Regulator Audit, Tickmill holds UK FCA (#717270), EU CySEC (#278/15), Dubai DFSA (#F007663), South Africa FSCA (#49464) (with native ZAR accounts and local instant EFT), Malaysia Labuan FSA (#MB/18/0028), and Seychelles FSA (#SD008). Vantage holds ASIC (#428901), UK FCA (#590299), South Africa FSCA (#51268), and Vanuatu VFSC (#700271), but lacks an EU CySEC or Labuan FSA license.
  2. Platforms & DMA Futures: Both brokers support MT4, MT5, and TradingView (Tickmill TradingView, MT4 & MT5 Guide). However, only Tickmill offers regulated Exchange-Traded DMA Futures & Options (CME, COMEX, NYMEX, CBOT, Eurex) via CQG, AgenaTrader, and TradingView ($1,000 min deposit).
  3. Leverage & Margin Management: Tickmill offers up to 1:1000 leverage with a 30% stop-out (Tickmill Leverage & Margin Rules), while Vantage offers up to 1:1000–1:2000 leverage. Always calculate your exact margin and stop-loss risk using our Margin Calculator and Position Size Calculator.
  4. Deposits & Withdrawals: Vantage allows a $50 entry vs Tickmill's $100 (Tickmill Minimum Deposit Guide), and both process zero-fee withdrawals within 1 business day (Tickmill Withdrawal Guide).

5. Final Verdict: Tickmill or Vantage Markets in 2026?

  • Choose Tickmill (Open a Tickmill Account) if you prioritize tighter raw spreads on EUR/USD and XAU/USD Gold, a $30 no-deposit Welcome Account, $2.00/lot VIP commissions ($50k+), real-cash 3.5% wallet interest and volume rebates, free TradingView subscription rebates, or regulated CME/Eurex DMA Futures.
  • Choose Vantage Markets (Open a Vantage Account) (or read our Vantage Review) if you want to start with a $50 minimum deposit, utilize 50% deposit credit bonuses, trade with 1:2000 leverage, or have between $10,000 and $49,999 to access the $3.00/lot Pro ECN tier.

Tickmill vs Vantage Markets: Your Questions Answered

How do Tickmill and Vantage Markets compare on Raw ECN commissions?

On entry-level ECN accounts, both Tickmill's Raw Account ($100 min deposit) and Vantage's Raw ECN Account ($50 min deposit) charge a competitive $3.00 per side ($6.00 round-turn per standard lot). However, Tickmill's average EUR/USD raw spreads (~0.10–0.20 pips) are tighter than Vantage Raw ECN (~0.15–0.25 pips), and Tickmill's VIP Account ($50,000 balance) charges just $2.00 round-turn vs Vantage's Pro ECN ($10,000 deposit) at $3.00 round-turn.

Which broker offers better promotions: Tickmill or Vantage?

Tickmill focuses on real-cash institutional perks: a $30 no-deposit Welcome Account, up to 3.5% APY interest on uninvested wallet cash, $0.25–$0.75/lot withdrawable cash rebates, and free TradingView subscription rebates. Vantage focuses on high-leverage deposit credit bonuses (50% first deposit bonus + 20% subsequent credit bonus) and its opt-in 13% p.a. funds promotion subject to daily volume requirements.

How does regulatory safety compare between Tickmill and Vantage Markets?

Both brokers hold UK FCA and South Africa FSCA licenses. However, Tickmill also holds a European Union CySEC license (#278/15 with €20,000 ICF coverage), Dubai DFSA registration (#F007663), Malaysia Labuan FSA license (#MB/18/0028), and Seychelles FSA license (#SD008). Vantage holds Australia ASIC (#428901), UK FCA (#590299), South Africa FSCA (#51268), and Vanuatu VFSC (#700271) licenses.

Does Tickmill or Vantage offer regulated Futures and Options trading?

Tickmill offers dedicated Direct Market Access (DMA) Futures and Options accounts ($1,000 minimum deposit) with live order-book routing to CME, COMEX, NYMEX, CBOT, and Eurex via CQG, AgenaTrader, and TradingView. Vantage only offers over-the-counter (OTC) CFDs across forex, indices, commodities, and shares.

Sources & verification

Last checked
Written by
HNL Growth Team
Reviewed by
Hà Ngọc Lộc
Length
7 min read

Rules, prices and payout terms on this page were checked against the official websites, help-centre articles and published terms of the firms mentioned, on the date above. Prop firms and brokers change conditions often — confirm the current version on the official site before you buy or deposit. Read our broker review methodology and affiliate disclosure.

Explore Related Hubs & Free Trading Tools

Head-to-Head Comparison

Check Each Broker for Your Country

Listed in no particular order. Each broker onboards you through a different legal entity depending on where you live — confirm the entity, its regulator, leverage cap and withdrawal terms before funding.

Tickmill logo
Tickmill 4.5/5
FCA #717270 · CySEC · FSCA · Raw $6/Lot

$100 Raw ($6/lot RT) & TradingView Raw ($7/lot) · 1:1000 Leverage · FCA/CySEC/FSCA/Labuan/FSA

Raw Account: 0.0 pips + $3.00/side ($6.00/lot RT)
TradingView Raw + Free TradingView Plan Rebate
$30 Welcome Account + up to 3.5% Wallet Interest
FCA #717270, CySEC & FSCA · Raw $6/Lot RT · $30 Welcome Account + 3.5% Wallet Interest
Vantage Markets logo
Vantage Markets 4.1/5
ASIC + FCA Tier-1 & Global

$50 Standard/Raw · MT4/MT5 + TradingView · FCA/ASIC & offshore entities

Raw ECN: $3/side commission
TradingView account connection
Leverage depends on entity
150% + 25% Deposit Credit (Offshore Entities Only)

Risk disclaimer: CFDs and leveraged forex are complex instruments and carry a high risk of losing money rapidly. Protections, leverage and available products depend on the entity that holds your account. Affiliate disclosure: HNL Growth may earn a commission when you open an account through broker links on this page.